Upcoming Workshop: Join us IN PERSON August 10th-11th in Carnation, WA — Click here for details!

The Trouble With Manhandling

by | Dec 8, 2011 | 1 comment

As a dog trainer and behavior consultant I work with a variety of dogs and a variety of dog behavior problems.  I have found gentle “hands-off” methods of working with dogs to be the most effective for  not only myself but for the dog owners I work with.  But I think it is important, especially for owners of giant breeds, to discuss why they, too, need to be as hands-off as the owners of toy breeds.  There are endless reasons for this, here are mine:

Most people canot physically out-muscle their dogs.  If you’re a professional body builder and you own a Havanese, you probably can, but in general people will struggle to physically overpower their dogs.  A dog trainer might be able to physically overpower a dog, especially if she has been trained in physical methods or is using equipment that makes this easier (choke or prong collar), but then asking the owner to do the same thing is asking for trouble.  No matter the method, if the dog’s owner fails to recreate what the trainer has achieved with the dog, the technique has failed.

When you get physical with your dog, you invite him to be physical with you.  I have found that dogs who have been physically corrected or manhandled take much more license with the body space of humans around them.  I believe that one of the most important things to teach dogs is to respect body space, and we can’t expect them to respect our bodies if we don’t respect theirs.  Two prime examples come to mind, the first is mouthy puppies, and the other is pushy giant or guardian breeds.  I have met many puppies with biting problems that go way beyond playful normal puppy mouthing, and every single one of these puppies are being physically corrected for biting by someone in the household.  Usually it begins with play-mouthing, the puppy gets nailed by a family member in some sort of scruff shake or smack, and then the biting escalates into a frenzy that spirals way out of control.  On the other hand I know a lot of giant breed dogs that simply like to throw their weight around.  Their owners failed to teach them good impulse control or body space respect and as these big dogs grew up they became so pushy their owners could do nothing but push back.  Then they are stuck with a dog that is too large to control physically but only responds to physicality because that is the only way he has been communicated with.  What a disaster!

And what about those dogs that learn they have no physical autonomy?  When humans take whatever liberties they deem necessary with dogs (like when owners of small dogs socialize them by handing them over to whomever would like to visit), dogs begin to act more aggressively than the situation calls for.  If your manhandling causes your Great Dane to shove his weight around it will teach your Pomeranian to bite and thrash at anyone who tries to touch him. 

What’s the moral of this story? Your hands should only be used to show your dog affection, and your dog will only respect your body space if you respect his.  In a future blog I will talk specifically about body space and how to teach dogs to recognize it, but for now just start to pause and think before you shove your dog into a position or yank on his leash.

1 Comment

  1. Tom

    One of the most heart-rending side-effects of physically forcing your dog (or becoming angry and harsh with your dog in just about any form) is that it damages the dog’s trust in the owner.

    I recently have been working with a dog that the owner claimed was “stubborn.” I asked the owner to demonstrate, and he commanded the dog to sit. The dog’s tail went between its legs, it averted its eyes from the owner and froze solid. The owner again bellowed “SIT!” The dog slowly and cautiously lowered its butt to the floor. When the owner walked away from the dog, I noticed a wet spot where the dog had urinated in fear.

    I asked the owner what other problems he was having with the dog, and he informed me the dog does not come when called, sneaks away into dark corners of the house to use the bathroom, and will evades the man when he tries to get the dog to come inside at night.

    This is not an example of a dog that is stubborn. It is an example of a dog who has been yelled at, forced, coerced and traumatized too many times.

    Force is the enemy of progress. Anger is the enemy of trust.



  1. Body Space Education « The Cognitive Canine - [...] without solicitation) the dog is being physically, sometimes harshly, corrected.  I’ve said it before, and I will say it again:…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Looking for more help from Sarah?

Pricing Starts at $47.00

Webinars & Courses

By Sarah Stremming

Choose from a variety of self-study courses and webinars ranging in topics from reactivity to crate training.

Adolescent dogs, multi-dog households, and even ringside sport skills are all here.

Pricing Starts at $79 Per Month

Cog Dog Membership

With Sarah Stremming

Can’t decide which course is for you? Want to see what the classroom has to offer and then some?

Valued at over $2500 with exclusive live events and access to community advice (and mine!), join the membership!

Custom Pricing

Private Coaching

With Sarah Stremming

For folks ready to do the deep work, who need help from me. Major behavior concerns, complex issues, and dedicated people come here to transform their current experience to more closely match the one they imagined. Availability is extremely limited, but the results are worth a wait.